Untrue

1. Female Infidelity: More Common and Complex Than Assumed

Other statistics range from as low as 13 percent to as high as 50 percent of women admitting they have been unfaithful to a spouse or partner; many experts suggest the numbers might well be higher, given the asymmetrical, searing stigma attached to being a woman who admits it.

Closing the gap. Contrary to popular belief, female infidelity is far from uncommon, with some estimates suggesting up to 50% of women admit to being unfaithful. Sociologists note that women are "closing the infidelity gap" with men, driven by increased autonomy, earning power, and digital connections. This challenges the long-held notion that infidelity is primarily a male domain.

Beyond stereotypes. The motivations behind female infidelity are often misunderstood. Many women who cheat are not necessarily unhappy in their marriages or seeking emotional connection; some, like those in Alicia Walker's study, are intentionally seeking sexual gratification and novelty that they lack at home. This contradicts the stereotype that women only cheat for love or intimacy.

"Unusual" is normal. Many women who express strong libidos or a desire for non-monogamy feel they are "unusual" or "outliers." However, the prevalence of these feelings suggests that societal definitions of "normal" female desire desperately need redefinition, acknowledging a wider spectrum of female sexual experience.

2. Societal Double Standards: The Enduring Stigma on Women

The adulteress has a noirish cast; she has stepped out of a 1950s divorce proceeding, perhaps.

Historical roots. The word "adulteress" itself is charged, evoking a sense of illicit femaleness and dishonesty, often with a historical, judgmental undertone. This contrasts sharply with the societal perception of male infidelity, which is often excused as "what men do." This double standard has deep historical roots, dating back to colonial laws that punished female adultery more severely than male fornication.

Consequences for women. The stigma attached to female infidelity can be devastating, leading to:

• Reputational assault and social shaming.
• Fear of divorce, financial hardship, and loss of custody.
• Internalized guilt and self-judgment, even when women feel justified in their actions.
  This fear often acts as a powerful constraint, preventing women from acting on their desires.

"Scarlet Mom" syndrome. Women like Sarah, who considered an affair, feared being labeled a "Scarlet Mom" by their communities, highlighting the unique social pressure on mothers to maintain an image of propriety. This societal judgment often outweighs personal desires or marital dissatisfaction, forcing women into difficult choices.

3. The "Plough Theory": How Agriculture Shaped Female Subordination

Simply put, a shift toward growing crops intensively for subsistence and later for profit changed everything between the sexes.

A historical turning point. Approximately ten to twelve thousand years ago, the rise of agriculture, particularly plough agriculture, fundamentally reorganized human societies. This shift, often hailed as "progress," had a profoundly negative impact on women, transforming them from relatively autonomous foragers into dependent, controlled figures.

Gendered division of labor. The physical demands of ploughing, which favored male strength and was incompatible with childcare, led to a rigid gendered division of labor: men worked outside in the fields, while women were relegated to domestic, "secondary" production. This created the enduring belief that "a woman's place is in the home."

Property and control. With the concept of private property emerging from agriculture, women became viewed as property themselves. Female monogamy became crucial to ensure legitimate paternity for inheritance, leading to widespread social control and legislation over women's bodies and sexuality. This legacy continues to influence gender roles and attitudes today, even in post-agrarian societies.

4. Female Desire: Strong, Diverse, and Driven by Novelty

That women are, on some level, super freaks. Our libidos don’t give a hoot about the boxes we check.

Beyond passive desire. Groundbreaking research by scientists like Meredith Chivers and Marta Meana challenges the long-held notion of women as the "less sexed" or "passive" sex. Studies show that women's physical arousal is often indiscriminate, responding to a wide range of stimuli regardless of sexual orientation, and that women report similar levels of sexual desire as men.

Novelty and self-focus. Women, like men, crave novelty and variety in sexual experiences. Marta Meana's work suggests that the familiarity of long-term relationships can dampen female desire, and that women often derive arousal from "erotic self-focus"—seeing themselves as sexy and desired. This highlights an independent aspect of female sexuality, not solely contingent on a partner.

Biological underpinnings. Female anatomy, particularly the richly innervated clitoris and the capacity for multiple orgasms, suggests a biological design for extensive pleasure-seeking and sexual experimentation. The human cervix, designed to filter multiple types of sperm, and male testicle size (larger than gorillas', similar to promiscuous chimps') also hint at a long evolutionary history of female multiple mating.

5. Context is Key: Environment Shapes Female Sexual Behavior

The interlocking, impossible-to-disentangle factors of biology, culture, and environmental circumstances mean sexual and social behaviors will be malleable; gamete production cannot explain or account for much beyond itself.

Himba women's choices. The Himba of Namibia offer a compelling example of how context shapes female infidelity. Despite arranged marriages, Himba women openly take lovers and have "omoka" (extra-marital) children. This is tolerated because:

• Fathers invest little in children, reducing the "cost" of paternity uncertainty.
• Children contribute to the group at a young age.
• Women maintain strong ties to their kin, providing support.
• There are few heritable resources, lessening concerns over inheritance.

Adaptive strategies. For Himba women in arranged marriages, having lovers and omoka children is a strategic "workaround" that can actually improve their reproductive success and provide additional support. This demonstrates that female "promiscuity" can be an adaptive and beneficial strategy under specific ecological and social conditions, directly challenging the idea of universal female monogamy.

Beyond the cage. The behavior of bonobos, our closest primate relatives, further illustrates the power of context. Unlike chimps, bonobos are female-dominant, female-bonded, and highly promiscuous, often using sex (especially female-female genito-genital contact) to build coalitions and diffuse tension. This suggests that if human females lived in similar female-centric, pleasure-focused environments, our sexual behaviors might be vastly different from current norms.

6. "Workarounds": Women's Strategies to Navigate Sexual Constraints

Their concurrent relationships were pragmatic and rather ingenious strategies to remain, on the surface, good wives and partners while getting the sex they felt they needed, not to mention a heady dose of novelty, variety, and excitement.

Secret lives. Many women, like Alicia Walker's study participants, engage in "infidelity workarounds" – secret affairs to gain sexual satisfaction while preserving their primary relationships. These women are often happily married but sexually unfulfilled, and they intentionally seek out partners for purely sexual encounters, demonstrating a pragmatic approach to desire.

The cost of secrecy. While providing desired sexual outlets, undisclosed non-monogamy is emotionally costly, leading to stress, guilt, and the constant fear of discovery. Annika's story highlights the exhaustion of maintaining secrets and the vulnerability that comes with financial dependence and lack of social support.

Open alternatives. Some couples, like Tim and Lily, choose consensual non-monogamy, openly agreeing to allow outside relationships. This requires immense trust, communication, and a commitment to prioritizing the primary relationship. For them, it's a way to embrace individual freedom while maintaining a strong, honest partnership, challenging the notion that openness inevitably leads to disaster.

7. Intersectionality: Unique Burdens on Black Women's Sexuality

To be a respectable black woman is to support and protect black men.

Controlling images. Black women face unique constraints on their sexual expression due to "controlling images" rooted in historical racism and slavery. Stereotypes like the "mammy," "ho," or "hypersexual" black woman distort social reality and justify oppression, making it perilous for Black women to express sexual autonomy without being deemed "unrespectable" or "deviant."

The church's influence. For many Black women, the church, while a source of community and strength, has also historically reinforced rigid gender and sexual norms, often prioritizing racial uplift over individual female sexual liberation. This creates a dilemma for women like Deesha Philyaw's characters, who navigate personal desires against community expectations of "respectability."

Online dating disparities. These controlling images manifest in contemporary contexts like online dating, where Black women report being subjected to racialized sexual assumptions and demeaning treatment from white men. This highlights how systemic biases continue to penalize Black women for simply seeking connection and sexual fulfillment.

8. Monogamy: A Cultural Construct, Not a Biological Imperative

Not a few anthropologists, taking the long and unsentimental view of these things, tell us monogamy and monogamous marriage are neither in our blood nor in our DNA.

A recent invention. Monogamy, particularly lifelong sexual exclusivity, is presented as a natural and universal human state, but anthropologists argue it's a relatively recent, imperfect species-wide compromise. Our ancestors likely lived as cooperative breeders, with loose bands raising young collectively and mating with multiple partners.

Challenging Bateman's Principle. The long-standing "Bateman paradigm," which asserted that males benefit from multiple matings while females do not (due to "cheap sperm" vs. "expensive eggs"), has been largely debunked. Modern research, including Patricia Adair Gowaty's replication studies, shows Bateman's findings were flawed and that male and female reproductive success rates tend to be equal.

Beyond biological determinism. The idea that men are "naturally" polygamous and women "naturally" monogamous is a cultural construct, not a biological truth. Our bodies are designed for pleasure and sexual variety, and our sexual behaviors are highly flexible, adapting to ecological and social circumstances rather than being rigidly determined by gamete production.

9. "Hotwifing" and Polyamory: Redefining Marital Norms

Many of these men, according to Ma—who interviewed several and dove into the world of online cuckold life via websites like Chatzy.com and CuckoldPlace.com—are what we might consider “alphas” in their day-to-day lives, hyper-masculine types who enjoy playing a decidedly beta role in their sex lives with their wives.

Cuckolding as fetish. The "cuckold lifestyle" or "hotwifing" involves husbands actively encouraging or witnessing their wives' infidelity for their own sexual arousal. This practice radically subverts traditional notions of male possession and control within marriage, with some men relishing a submissive role.

Unexpected benefits. For some couples, like Alexis McCall and her husband, hotwifing has counterintuitively strengthened their marriage, fostering deeper intimacy and communication. It can provide a sanctioned outlet for female desire and novelty, preventing the relationship from becoming "sexless" or "boring."

Agency and complexity. While hotwifing can empower women by giving them sexual freedom, it can also be complex. Some men may rigidly choreograph their wives' experiences, and racial fetishes (e.g., "Mandingos") can perpetuate harmful stereotypes. However, many women in these arrangements report developing greater sexual autonomy and independence over time.

10. The Future: Towards Greater Female Sexual Liberation

It seems reasonable to hope that, one day, we will not automatically and unthinkingly judge ourselves guilty, or will at least develop the capacity to absolve ourselves of sin.

Evolving norms. The increasing visibility of consensual non-monogamy, female sexual fluidity, and diverse sexual practices (like Skirt Club) suggests a cultural shift. While resistance and backlash persist, these phenomena challenge rigid categories and push for a more nuanced understanding of human sexuality.

Reclaiming narratives. Artists and activists like Issa Rae, Deesha Philyaw, Mireille Miller-Young, and Frenchie Davis are actively reshaping narratives around female sexuality, particularly for Black women. By portraying complex, authentic female characters and challenging stereotypes, they pave the way for greater acceptance and self-determination.

The path forward. True female sexual autonomy requires dismantling both external constraints (societal judgment, economic dependence) and internal ones (guilt, self-censure). As women gain more resources and societal structures become less rigid, the possibilities for diverse and fulfilling sexual lives, free from historical burdens, will expand.

Last updated: August 1, 2025