Key Takeaways
1. Embrace the 'Evil Impulse' as a Source of Creativity and Growth
The yetzer hara is a warehouse for our curiosity, ambition, and potency—it's the yeast in the dough.
Reframe negative traits. Instead of viewing your child's challenging behaviors as purely negative, recognize them as potential strengths in disguise. For example:
- Stubbornness can indicate persistence
- Argumentativeness may reflect critical thinking skills
- Restlessness might signal creativity and energy
By acknowledging these traits as part of your child's unique personality, you can guide them to channel these impulses constructively. Encourage activities that allow for positive expression of these traits, such as debate clubs for argumentative children or sports for those with high energy.
Foster self-awareness. Help your child understand their own tendencies and how to manage them. This self-knowledge will serve them well throughout life, enabling them to harness their natural inclinations for success rather than being controlled by them.
2. Teach Children Self-Reliance Through Moderate Risk-Taking
Real protection means teaching children to manage risks on their own, not shielding them from every hazard.
Encourage age-appropriate independence. Allow your children to tackle challenges that stretch their abilities without overwhelming them. This might include:
- Walking to a nearby friend's house alone (for older children)
- Ordering their own meal at a restaurant
- Resolving conflicts with siblings without parental intervention
Balance safety with growth opportunities. While it's natural to want to protect your children, excessive sheltering can hinder their development. Assess risks realistically and let your children experience minor setbacks or failures. These experiences build resilience and problem-solving skills.
Provide a safety net, but don't rescue them from every difficulty. Be available for support and guidance, but allow them to navigate obstacles on their own when possible.
3. Cultivate Gratitude to Counter Materialism and Entitlement
If you place too high a value on straight-A report cards and a slateful of extracurricular activities, your child may feel that she needs to excel in all areas in order to retain your respect.
Model appreciation. Regularly express gratitude for both big and small things in your life. This can include:
- Verbalizing thanks for a meal or act of kindness
- Keeping a family gratitude journal
- Discussing the efforts behind the things you enjoy (e.g., the farmers who grew your food)
Encourage giving and service. Help your children understand their place in the larger community by involving them in acts of kindness and charity. This might include:
- Volunteering at a local food bank
- Donating toys or clothes to those in need
- Participating in community clean-up efforts
By shifting focus from acquiring things to appreciating what they have and helping others, children develop a more balanced perspective on material possessions and personal worth.
4. Assign Age-Appropriate Chores to Foster Responsibility
Ordinary chores are the foundation of our children's character and spiritual well-being.
Start early and increase gradually. Introduce simple tasks from a young age and expand responsibilities as children grow. Examples might include:
- Ages 2-3: Picking up toys, helping to feed pets
- Ages 4-5: Setting the table, sorting laundry
- Ages 6-8: Making their bed, helping with meal preparation
- Ages 9-11: Doing their own laundry, basic cleaning tasks
Connect chores to family contribution. Frame household tasks as a way of contributing to the family's well-being rather than as punishments or burdens. Explain how each person's efforts make life better for everyone.
Acknowledge and appreciate their work, but avoid excessive praise or rewards. The goal is to instill a sense of intrinsic satisfaction from contributing and being capable.
5. Balance Nutrition with Celebration in Family Meals
In Judaism, there is a place for both nutrition and delight.
Prioritize family meals. Make regular shared meals a non-negotiable part of family life. This provides opportunities for:
- Modeling healthy eating habits
- Practicing conversation skills
- Strengthening family bonds
Incorporate tradition and joy. While focusing on nutrition is important, don't neglect the celebratory aspects of food. Consider:
- Having special meals for holidays or family milestones
- Involving children in meal planning and preparation
- Exploring foods from different cultures
Balance everyday healthy meals with occasional treats or indulgences. This teaches moderation and helps prevent an overly restrictive or anxious relationship with food.
6. Implement Consistent Discipline with Compassion
The purpose of discipline is to teach both new attitudes and new behaviors.
Establish clear expectations. Set rules and boundaries that are appropriate for your child's age and development. Communicate these clearly and consistently.
Use logical consequences. When rules are broken, implement consequences that are:
- Related to the misbehavior
- Respectful of the child
- Reasonable in duration and severity
For example, if a child refuses to wear a bike helmet, they lose bike-riding privileges until they agree to wear it.
Focus on teaching, not punishing. Frame discipline as an opportunity for learning and growth. Help your child understand the reasons behind rules and the impact of their actions on others.
7. Create Sacred Time for Family Connection and Reflection
Shabbat dinner is a good place to start, and so are family birthday dinners (separate from the actual party) or leisurely Sunday breakfasts with "ritual" foods your family loves.
Establish regular rituals. Create consistent times for family connection, such as:
- Weekly family game nights
- Monthly outings to explore nature or local attractions
- Annual traditions around holidays or birthdays
Protect these times. Treat these family rituals as sacred by:
- Turning off phones and other distractions
- Declining other invitations or commitments that conflict
- Involving all family members in planning and preparation
These dedicated times provide opportunities for deeper conversations, shared experiences, and the transmission of family values and stories.
8. Introduce Spirituality Through Everyday Experiences
To meet God we have to be like detectives and look for clues. Just as a candle hidden from view sheds its glow all around, we can see God in God's reflection: in the good things people do for one another, in the miracles of nature, in our ability to change and grow.
Cultivate wonder and awe. Help children notice and appreciate the marvelous in the mundane:
- Point out intricate patterns in nature
- Discuss the vastness of the universe
- Explore the complexity of the human body
Connect ethics to spirituality. Frame moral choices and kind actions as ways of honoring the divine or participating in the improvement of the world.
Use everyday occurrences as springboards for spiritual discussions. A beautiful sunset, an act of kindness witnessed, or a challenging situation can all serve as opportunities to explore deeper meanings and values.
9. Adapt Parenting Approach to Each Child's Unique Nature
Judaism holds that our children don't belong to us. They are both a loan and a gift from God, and the gift has strings attached. Our job is to raise our children to leave us.
Observe and understand. Pay close attention to your child's:
- Temperament (e.g., shy or outgoing, cautious or adventurous)
- Learning style (visual, auditory, kinesthetic)
- Interests and natural talents
Tailor your approach. Adjust your parenting strategies to fit each child's needs:
- For a highly sensitive child, provide more preparation for transitions
- For a kinesthetic learner, incorporate movement into learning activities
- For an introverted child, respect their need for alone time to recharge
Support their journey. Remember that your role is to guide and support, not to mold your child into a preconceived image. Help them discover and develop their own unique potential, even if it differs from your expectations or desires.
Last updated:
Review Summary
The Blessing of a Skinned Knee receives high praise for its practical parenting advice rooted in Jewish teachings. Readers appreciate Mogel's emphasis on moderation, celebration, and sanctification in daily life. The book offers guidance on fostering resilience, gratitude, and self-reliance in children. Many non-Jewish readers find the principles universally applicable. Some criticize the book's focus on middle-to-upper-class families and occasional outdated perspectives. Overall, readers value Mogel's insights on balancing authority with love and teaching children to appreciate their blessings.